{
  "version": "0.6.5",
  "map_id": "HIT-COE-V0.6.5",
  "scope": "H1 through H9 and four material claims in the working paper. Unmapped repository prose remains outside this audit.",
  "fitness_dimensions": ["directness", "contemporaneity", "independence", "completeness", "publication_authority"],
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim_id": "H1", "claim_text": "HIT represents six substantive dimensions and split Telemetry Integrity in a machine-readable assessment.", "claim_class": "structural", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H1-SCHEMA", "path": "schema/hit-assessment.schema.json", "locator": "telemetry_integrity", "role": "contract", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "H1-CATALOG", "path": "schema/hit-dimension-catalog.json", "locator": "catalog_version", "role": "contract", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The schema and catalog define the represented fields."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns the current artifact."}, "independence": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "Independent evidence is not required for structural representation."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Both normative machine-readable components are included."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository publishes its own contract."}},
      "dependencies": [], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["Representation does not establish construct validity."], "reversal_conditions": ["A required construct cannot be represented by the contract."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H2", "claim_text": "The evidence-state and finding rules distinguish affirmative absence, ceremonial presence, substantive exercise, and insufficient evidence in the executable boundary suite.", "claim_class": "methodological", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H2-FIXTURES", "path": "fixtures/v0.4.0-boundaries/rubric-boundary-fixtures.json", "locator": "cases", "role": "contract", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "H2-RULES", "path": "src/rubric/rules_v040.py", "locator": "evaluate", "role": "implementation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Fixtures exercise the declared distinctions."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns executable contract behavior."}, "independence": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The bounded claim concerns internal tests."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The published boundary suite covers the declared rule families."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository is authoritative for its tests."}},
      "dependencies": ["H1"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["Synthetic cases do not establish empirical correctness."], "reversal_conditions": ["A declared boundary case produces the wrong state."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H3", "claim_text": "Two eligible independent reviewers reached the predeclared threshold on one frozen Cigna packet under the preserved 0.1.0 scorer contract.", "claim_class": "empirical", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H3-RESULT", "path": "validation/results/pre-adjudication-comparison.json", "locator": "exact_agreements", "role": "result", "integrity": "locked_digest", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "H3-BOUNDARY", "path": "validation/results/H3-maturity-decision.md", "locator": "Level 2, Applicable", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The locked comparison directly records agreement."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The result was produced from the locked submissions."}, "independence": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The protocol records two eligible independent scorers."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Both submissions and the comparison are preserved."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository publishes its own protocol result."}},
      "dependencies": ["H1"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["The result covers one case, two scorers, seven items, and contract 0.1.0.", "It does not estimate general reliability or replicate the 0.4.0 contract."], "reversal_conditions": ["Recomputation differs from the preserved comparison or scorer eligibility fails."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H4", "claim_text": "HIT can classify ceremonial oversight where a binary human-presence label would record human involvement.", "claim_class": "methodological", "status": "provisional",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H4-CASE", "path": "case-studies/assessments/cigna-pxdx.json", "locator": "findings", "role": "result", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "H4-LIMIT", "path": "LIMITATIONS.md", "locator": "Narrow reliability evidence", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The assessment records ceremonial findings."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "The retrospective public record does not expose every decision-time event."}, "independence": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The human exercise independently reproduced the categorical findings for one packet."}, "completeness": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "Public records may omit internal practice."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The claim is limited to HIT classification behavior."}},
      "dependencies": ["H2", "H3"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "indeterminate", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["External replication under the current contract remains unresolved."], "reversal_conditions": ["Current-contract applications fail to distinguish ceremonial presence."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H5", "claim_text": "Higher HIT findings predict lower harm or better repair.", "claim_class": "hypothesis", "status": "blocked",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H5-REGISTER", "path": "RESEARCH.md", "locator": "H5 |", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "No preregistered outcome study tests this relation."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "No study population exists."}, "independence": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "No independent outcome evidence exists."}, "completeness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "Population, outcomes, and statistical method are absent."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "No result is asserted."}},
      "dependencies": ["H4"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "fail", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["This is an untested hypothesis."], "reversal_conditions": ["A preregistered study estimates the stated relationship."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H6", "claim_text": "A high HIT finding proves meaningful human control in a causal or legal sense.", "claim_class": "boundary", "status": "unsupported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H6-SPEC", "path": "SPECIFICATION.md", "locator": "does not", "role": "contract", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "Documentary findings cannot prove causal or legal status."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim is rejected as outside the method."}, "independence": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim is rejected as outside the method."}, "completeness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "The required causal and legal evidence is absent."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "HIT disclaims this authority."}},
      "dependencies": [], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "fail", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["The method supplies documentary assessment only."], "reversal_conditions": ["A separate validated causal or legal method is added with qualified review."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H7", "claim_text": "HIT evidence may inform external oversight, accountability, and contestability analysis within a separately reviewed applicability boundary.", "claim_class": "publication", "status": "provisional",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H7-BOUNDARY", "path": "docs/adjacent-system-boundaries.md", "locator": "boundary", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The boundary analysis identifies possible uses."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns analytical applicability."}, "independence": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "Qualified external review is absent."}, "completeness": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "Jurisdiction-specific applicability is incomplete."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "HIT has no authority to determine legal compliance."}},
      "dependencies": ["H1"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "indeterminate", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["No legal or standards conformity claim is permitted."], "reversal_conditions": ["Qualified review closes a defined applicability claim."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H8", "claim_text": "HIT has been independently adopted by an institution outside the author's control.", "claim_class": "adoption", "status": "blocked",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H8-REGISTER", "path": "RESEARCH.md", "locator": "H8 |", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "No adoption record exists."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "No adoption event exists."}, "independence": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "No institution outside the author's control has supplied evidence."}, "completeness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "The required adoption evidence is absent."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "No adopter assertion exists."}},
      "dependencies": [], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "fail", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["No independent institutional adoption is recorded."], "reversal_conditions": ["An external institution documents operational use."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "H9", "claim_text": "The public HIT package can be installed, operated, and explained without private author interpretation.", "claim_class": "methodological", "status": "pending",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "H9-PACKET", "path": "implementation/v1.0.0-candidate/audit-protocol.md", "locator": "HIT-CRI-V100-001", "role": "method", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "The protocol exists, while execution remains pending."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns package usability."}, "independence": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "No clean-room reviewer result exists."}, "completeness": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "The candidate packet has not completed audit."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository can state its audit status."}},
      "dependencies": ["H1", "H2"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "fail", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["The clean-room implementation audit is incomplete."], "reversal_conditions": ["An eligible reviewer completes HIT-CRI-V100-001."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "PAPER-C01", "claim_text": "HIT is a documentary assurance method with a stable 0.4.0 normative contract and a separate 0.5.0 conformance engine.", "claim_class": "publication", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "PC01-COMPAT", "path": "compatibility/hit-compatibility-manifest.json", "locator": "engine_version", "role": "metadata", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Compatibility metadata identifies both versions."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns published software state."}, "independence": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The repository is authoritative for its versions."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Both relevant component versions are recorded."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository publishes the method."}},
      "dependencies": ["H1", "H2"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["Version separation does not establish external validity."], "reversal_conditions": ["A component boundary changes without compatible metadata."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "PAPER-C02", "claim_text": "The published human result is bounded to one frozen packet and does not resolve current-contract replication.", "claim_class": "publication", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "PC02-RESULT", "path": "docs/releases/v0.6.0.md", "locator": "7 of 7", "role": "result", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "PC02-REPLICATION", "path": "validation/v0.7.0/recruitment-contingency.md", "locator": "scoring", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The release and contingency documents state the two boundaries."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Both describe the current repository state."}, "independence": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The bounded result used independent scorers."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The sentence states both available and missing evidence."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository publishes both statuses."}},
      "dependencies": ["H3"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["Current-contract external-rater replication remains unresolved."], "reversal_conditions": ["A locked current-contract replication result is published."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "PAPER-C03", "claim_text": "The v0.6.5 audit detects its prespecified corruptions and blocks mapped claims whose required gates do not pass.", "claim_class": "publication", "status": "supported",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "PC03-AUDIT", "path": "audits/v0.6.5/audit-results.json", "locator": "negative_controls", "role": "result", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}, {"evidence_id": "PC03-CODE", "path": "scripts/run_research_integrity_audit.py", "locator": "run_negative_controls", "role": "implementation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Generated audit output records each control and gate."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The output is regenerated from the v0.6.5 inputs."}, "independence": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "The claim concerns deterministic internal controls."}, "completeness": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "Every declared negative control is reported."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "pass", "rationale": "The repository publishes its control behavior."}},
      "dependencies": ["PAPER-C01", "PAPER-C02"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "pass", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": true, "limitations": ["Control detection does not establish that external sources are true."], "reversal_conditions": ["A prespecified corruption escapes detection."]
    },
    {
      "claim_id": "PAPER-C04", "claim_text": "HIT has established population-wide inter-rater reliability under the current 0.4.0 contract.", "claim_class": "publication", "status": "blocked",
      "evidence": [{"evidence_id": "PC04-CONTINGENCY", "path": "validation/v0.7.0/recruitment-contingency.md", "locator": "replication", "role": "limitation", "integrity": "git_tracked", "support_review": "recorded"}],
      "fitness": {"directness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "No current-contract replication result exists."}, "contemporaneity": {"state": "indeterminate", "rationale": "Scoring is prohibited."}, "independence": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "External raters have not completed the current protocol."}, "completeness": {"state": "fail", "rationale": "The planned cases and submissions are absent."}, "publication_authority": {"state": "outside_scope", "rationale": "No result may be published."}},
      "dependencies": ["H3", "H4"], "declared_gates": {"traceability": "pass", "integrity": "pass", "human_support_review": "pass", "evidence_fitness": "fail", "dependency_closure": "pass"}, "conclusion_eligible": false, "limitations": ["External-rater replication remains separate and unresolved."], "reversal_conditions": ["The locked current-contract protocol produces a qualifying public result."]
    }
  ]
}